Chris_Xa wrote:Have not seen it yet (assume you're referring to the Lorre 1931ish german film?), but have always heard good things about it. Re sound, the best films use sound (or lack of) to accentuate what is happening on screen. Many films for me have been ruined by music that signposts what is coming, whilst others use lack-of-music to great effect; Gravity is a good example of the latter.Davy_Lee wrote:M (First viewing, YouTube) - 9/10
I have been on the fence about buying the blu-ray because this is an early sound film which, I thought, should have serious flaws in its sound design. I was wrong!
I like silent films but not early talkies, which is the reason why I haven't added M into my collection. Granted, M doesn't have any musical score to accompany the scenes, which I have always thought would bore the audience, but strangely the fact proves to be the opposite. I was glued to the screen for almost the entire run time. Another surprising aspect of M is that, despite having a very serious theme, it is peppered with light humour in many of the scenes.
Initially, I was curious to find out why this detective thriller has received so many positive reviews from film scholars. Now I know why and couldn't agree more. This is one of the early talkies that deserves very high recommendation.
That era was probably the best era of German cinema; to me it was the premier cinema industry of the world (1920s-early1930s, before the Nazis stomped in and ruined it). Other great films of then is METROPOLIS (pleased we finally have a complete version available), NOSFERATU (whilst not a great movie in itself, it is one of the best vampire films; for me the best vampire film ever is VAMPIRE HUNTER D: BLOODLUST), etc.
Yes Chris, it's the 1931 film that Fritz Lang directed. For some reasons, early talkies don't appeal to me. But M is an exception partly because of the plot which incorporates these interesting elements: child murderer, police investigations, kangaroo court and thriller. Other notable factors include Peter Lorre's performance, cinematography and of course Lang's direction. For a film of the 30's, it's phenomenal. However, this may not be your cup of tea as one's preference for movies very much depends on various factors.
After M, I may watch Lang's two other works too - Dr. Mabuse and The Testament of Dr. Mabuse, which belong to the detective thriller genre.